20 Bourbon Whiskeys to Try in 2019, At Every Price Point

Updated 06/27/19

Graphic by Cristina Cianci

Mark Twain once said, “Too much of anything is bad, but too much good whiskey is barely enough.” To that end, we’ve compiled a list of a few of the best bourbon whiskeys, including a sampling of the best bourbon under $50. These are sure to elevate your home bar, after-hours cocktail order, or reputation for home entertaining. Whether you’re a seasoned bourbon lover or a budding whiskey enthusiast, these bourbons will definitely bring out your taste for the finer things. Read on for eight of the best bourbon whiskeys to keep at your home bar or give as a gift.

What is Bourbon?

Bourbon is a type of American whiskey that is distilled from a corn mash. It's distinctly made in America.

Four Roses

While we’re in love with the small-batch and single-barrel variations, even the flagship iteration of Four Roses is a stellar addition to any home bar. This is one of the best bourbons under $50 hands down, and while it’s ideal for simple mixed drinks, it’s also smooth enough for sipping on the rocks. Look for light notes of pear, raw honey, and apple. And if you doubt that bourbon is an art form, consider that at 130 years, Four Roses has been in business longer than most Swiss watchmakers.

Four Roses Single Barrel Bourbon $40
Shop

Booker's

A true bourbon lover’s bourbon, Booker’s is rife with dark, rich tasting notes like leather, oak, caramel, and spice. Bartender Colin Longstaff of Wolf & Long notes, “If you’re a bourbon drinker like me, someone who likes a drink that is sweet, smoky, and flavorful but that could also strip paint off the side of your house, I would go with a glass (or bottle) of Booker’s. At around 120 proof, the high alcohol doesn’t hinder the rich oak, chocolate, and toffee flavors. An excellent choice for any occasion.”

Booker's Sip Awhile Bourbon $66
Shop

Willett

One of the top bourbon whiskeys at a very fair price point, Willett Pot Still Reserve is an ideal addition to any home bar. With elements of lightly fragrant citrus and warm vanilla, this is one for the rocks. (And the bottle alone is worth putting this bourbon on your shelf.)

Willett Pot Still Reserve Bourbon $85
Shop

Blanton's

If you tend to gauge the best bourbon whiskeys by how cool the bottles are (and who can blame you), Blanton’s is a must. Beneath a top that looks like a missing Monopoly game piece, this bourbon carries luscious notes of burnt sugar, orange peel, and cloves. Enjoy it neat or with a single large cube of ice to open up the fragrance and flavors.

Blanton's Bourbon $57
Shop

Old Forester

At $18 a bottle, Old Forester provides one of the best affordable bourbons. Bring this to your next get together or give it as a gift. Its smooth, mild flavor contains notes of caramel, cherry, and clove, making it a great pairing for a winter or holiday drink.

Old Forester Bourbon $18
Shop

Hudson

Sometimes the best things come in small packages, and Hudson Baby Bourbon is no exception. While the majority of bourbons are associated with distilling in Kentucky, this is the first New York–aged whiskey to be made since Prohibition, giving it a historical edge with contemporary appeal. Tasting notes include smoky caramel, marzipan, and rich oak.

Hudson Baby Bourbon Whiskey $56
Shop

Buffalo Trace

Strong but not overpowering, Buffalo Trace is full-on Kentucky straight bourbon. With notes of toffee, candied fruit, and vanilla, this is an ideal bourbon for classic cocktails like Old Fashioneds and Paper Planes. At over 200 years old, Buffalo Trace hails from one of the oldest (and most award-winning) distilleries in the United States.

Buffalo Trace Bourbon $24
Shop

Basil Hayden's

With an ultra-smooth, unobtrusively sophisticated profile, this is one of the best bourbon whiskeys to add to your collection. Unlike a number of more citric whiskeys, Basil Hayden’s carries tasting notes of dark fruit, walnut, cinnamon, and a touch of mint. While you wouldn’t guess it from the bottle, it’s also one of the best bourbons under $50.

Basil Hayden's Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey $26
Shop

Angel's Envy

What makes Angel's Envy Bourbon unique is its port barrel finish, lending this bourbon a complex yet balanced palate—think vanilla bundt cake, mint, orange, cinnamon with whispers of burnt sugar. And, like a good port, the finish is long, with flavors of walnut and oak.

Bottle of Angel's Envy Bourbon
Angel's Envy Bourbon $47
Shop

Firestone & Robertson Distilling Co.

Fort Worth-based craft distillers Firestone & Robertson make their bourbon using local grains and a proprietary yeast strain from a Texas pecan, lending flavors of dried fruit, sweet spice, and floral notes. This bourbon is smooth and sells fast.

Bottle of Firestone & Robertson Distilling Co. TX Bourbon
Firestone & Robertson Distilling Co. TX Bourbon $50
Shop

Noah's Mill

Noah's Mill bourbon is lush and rich, with aromas reminiscent of walnuts, prunes, and floral notes. On the palate, a similar profile mixes with lavender and is offset with just the right amount of acid and a burnt caramel finish.

Bottle of Noah's Mill Bourbon
Noah's Mill Small Batch Bourbon $55
Shop

Eagle Rare

As a bourbon aged for at least 10 years at its Kentucky distillery, Eagle Rare Bourbon Whiskey is part of Buffalo Trace's flagship whiskey collection. It's complex on the nose, with toffee, leather, honey, and citrus aromas, while the taste is nuanced with candied almonds and rich cocoa notes.

Bottle of Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon
Eagle Rare 10 Year Bourbon $49
Shop

High Wire

In another departure from standard bourbons, High Wire Distilling's features bourbon made from a variety of corn (Jimmy Red), once on the brink of extinction. The effect on the palate means a sweeter, nuttier, complex profile—a unique characteristic of a bourbon made entirely from corn.

Bottle of High Wire Distilling 100% Jimmy Red Corn Bourbon Whiskey
High Wire Distilling Co. 100% Jimmy Red Corn Straight Bourbon $128
Shop

Jefferson's Reserve

Jefferson's is known for innovative, small-batch blends, and its 2018 release features a bourbon aged in flash-charred barrels for optimal oaky flavor. The oak also offers the palate a balanced, simultaneously sweet and spicy profile with a medium-length finish of cedar and tart lemon.

Bottle of Jefferson's Reserve Twin Oak Bourbon
Jefferson's Reserve Twin Oak Bourbon $78
Shop

High West

Drinking American Prairie bourbon is like sipping on rich and earthy goodness, with welcoming notes of honey, sweet corn bread biscuits, and a dash of Granny Smith apple. Plus, a portion of every bottle purchased is donated to American Prairie Reserve, a non-profit committed to the stewardship of the country's natural resources.

Bottle of High West American Prairie Bourbon
High West American Prairie Bourbon $35
Shop

Watershed

This Columbus, Ohio-based Watershed Distillery adds spelt grain to make their bourbon, or a version of wheat that is rarely used in distilling. Cool, but how does it taste? Think grassy and oat flavors, with an added sweetness that might be honey, or gingerbread. Take a sniff, and you'll get notes of cedar and pine.

Bottle of Watershed Distillery Bourbon Whiskey
Watershed Distillery Bourbon Whiskey $57
Shop

Heaven Hill

Those in the know are aware that Heaven Hill's steal of a bourbon, while almost exclusively found in Kentucky, is a great sipping and mixing bourbon for the price. This bourbon touts notes of cinnamon spice and sweetness, as well as apple, brown sugar, and peanut flavors on the palate.

Bottle of Heaven Hill Green Label 6 Year Bourbon
Heaven Hill Bourbon Green Label 6 Year $15
Shop

Koval

For a fruitier bourbon (think mango chutney and soft vanilla notes), Koval's organic corn and millet-based bourbon is a top-notch choice. Bourbon aficionados seeking experimental or unusual whiskeys have been known to put this bourbon at the top of their lists.

Bottle of Koval Bourbon Whiskey
Koval Bourbon Whiskey $43
Shop

I.W. Harper

After falling out of popularity and closing operations in the '90s, I.W. Harper is back making their sweet, corn-rich bourbons. Spices like nutmeg enhance a bready flavor profile of shortbread or cookie dough with a lingering, oaky finish. Fun Fact: During Prohibition, the company was one of only 10 distilleries allowed to make medicinal bourbon.

Bottle of I.W. Harper Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
I.W. Harper Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey $36
Shop

Woodford

This Kentucky-produced bourbon invites imbibers to inhale notes of vanilla, orange, and oak. On the palate, taste notes of charred orange, brown sugar, and dried fruits with slight astringency on the finish.

Bottle of Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey
Woodford Reserve Kentucky Straight Bourbon Whiskey $40
Shop

Related Stories