Sommeliers Have Spoken: The Best 7 Cheap Wines Taste Super Expensive

Woman holding two glasses of wine

Photo by Justin Aikin on Unsplash

Anyone who's ventured down the wine aisle at Whole Foods can attest that selecting the right bottle involves navigating dozens of seemingly similar options. It's a minefield of varietals, labels, and price tags, which is made all the more daunting when you scarcely know your reds from your whites or you're on a tight budget. Thankfully, and contrary to popular belief, a great-tasting bottle of wine doesn't necessarily need to be procured at an eye-watering price. To learn a thing or two about stocking our bar cart on a budget, we asked sommeliers and wine directors to weigh in on the best cheap wines that taste expensive.

Ahead, the pros recommend palate-pleasing bottles ranging from a full-bodied jammy red that pairs well with comfort foods (like grilled cheese and beef stew) to a sweet, dry Chenin blanc ideal for sipping outside when it's 72-and-sunny. If you have Champagne taste but you're on a sparkling wine budget, each expert-recommended bottle here costs just $15 or less. These are the best cheap wine options that we'll be sipping all year-round.

Dry Creek Vineyard Dry Chenin Blanc 2017
Dry Creek Vineyard Dry Chenin Blanc 2018 $14

"In the right hands, Chenin Blanc can be made into world-class wine," explains sommelier Jeremy Allen of MiniBar in Hollywood. "Outside of France, it's made into extremely delicious and inexpensive wine. It's the most planted varietal in South Africa, and between South Africa and California, there are Chenins made for chugging and Chenins made for pairing and pondering."

Badenhorst The Curator White Blend 2016
Badenhorst The Curator White Blend 2019 $11

Chenin Blanc "has enough body and sweetness to pair with spice and enough acidity to drink on its own when it's hot out," according to Allen. This bottle (and the Dry Creek Vineyard one above) has enough "versatility to please a range of discerning palates—unique enough to impress and approachable enough to please a crowd," the sommelier adds.

di Majo Norante Aglianico del Molise Riserva Contado 2012
Mastroberardino Aglianico 2014 $13

"For those seeking a full-bodied red wine with more earth and muscle than soft fruit and a 'jammy' character, meet this delicious Aglianico from southern Italy," says sommelier Claire Coppi of Mirabelle Wine Bar in Los Angeles. "On the nose, the ripe dark fruits and a hint of orange are balanced by notes of pipe tobacco, leather, spice, and cedar. The velvety tannins make this an excellent wine to pair with hearty stews, game, brisket, or aged cheeses. And for $13 a bottle, this Aglianico is a real bargain!"

Bodegas Mustiguillo Mestizaje Tinto Mestizaje Tinto 2016
Bodegas Mustiguillo Mestizaje Tinto Mestizaje Tinto 2017 $13

"Spain has a wealth of native varietals that are not known to most wine consumers, and the quality to price ratio is off the charts compared to most traditional winemaking countries," offers Ben Teig, wine director at Redbird in downtown Los Angeles. "Bobal is a grape that is native to Spain and Bodegas Mustiguillo specializes in this grape. The winery is part of the Pago D.O., which means they are outside of the traditional appellation laws but have been recognized as having exceptional quality and all of the fruit is estate grown. This wine is very flexible when pairing with food, pairing with a myriad of different dishes or just as an aperitif as well."

Bodegas Breca Garnacha de Fuego 2016
Bodegas Breca Garnacha de Fuego 2016 $10

"We've all heard of the great Spanish red and white wines of Rioja but right next door in Catatyud D.O., Bodegas Breca is producing wine of exceptional quality from the oldest clones of garnacha in the world," says Bill Giering, wine director at The Rose Venice in Venice, California. "Called garnacha de Aragon, it is harvested from 90-year-old vines planted on hillside quartz- and slate-dominant vineyards 900 feet above sea level to produce its impressive Garnacha de Fuego 2016. It's a wine whose deep purple color adds to an initial experience of black currants and plum which is only to be balanced by full-bodied notes of black licorice and dark smoky earth."

Santa Rita Carmenere Reserva 2015
Santa Rita Carmenere Reserva 2015 $15

"This wine is great any time of year," recommends Amy Racine, wine director for The Loyal in Manhattan's West Village. "It goes really well with BBQ in the summer and roasted veggies during the winter. It's a fun spicy grape (carmenere) that cabernet sauvignon lovers would really enjoy if they're looking to try something different. The vineyard also invests in sustainable winemaking and farming, resulting in a very low carbon footprint."

Skouras Moscofilero 2017
Skouras Moscofilero 2019 $14

"I had the opportunity to meet with George Skouras, the winemaker and owner of Domaine Skouras while I was in Greece, and fell in love with his Moscofilero," confesses Jessica Altieri, wine and water sommelier at the Four Seasons Resort Palm Beach. "This is an aromatic white grape varietal from the Peloponnese with beautiful white floral, honeysuckle, and citrus aromas and flavors. This elegant wine is a fantastic value and has a crisp, refreshing finish that would be a perfect pairing with the octopus." 

Favorite Wine-Friendly Finds

Decorate your bar cart with these useful and stylish accessories.

Vintage Etched Wine Decanter
Williams Sonoma Vintage Etched Wine Decanter $70
Geode Bottle Stopper
Target Geode Bottle Stopper $8
Wine bottle in a wine coaster
Crate & Barrel Wood and Marble Wine Coaster $20
Wine glass with white wine
Food52 Schott Zwiesel Vervino White Wine Glasses $34 $26
Gold corkscrew
Goop Porter Corkscrew $68

Related Stories