The Very Best Comforters on Amazon, According to Thousands of Reviews

Updated 06/01/19

Sara Tramp; DESIGN: Emily Henderson Design 

Online shopping is both a blessing and a curse. Simply clicking "add to cart" and waiting for a package to arrive is a modern luxury; however, a digital shopping spree also involves the difficult task of picking one item from seemingly endless options. Plus, something as personal as choosing the bedding you'll unwind in night after night shouldn't be done so blindly over a screen. However, since we prefer to shop from the comfort of our couch, the only way to ensure a return isn't in your future is to sift through thousands of reviews from people who've received and tested the product you're thinking of purchasing. 

Since nobody has the time to vet hundreds of pages of reviews (even if it means doing so from bed, in your pajamas), we took the liberty of scouring through thousands of Amazon reviews for you. Here, a simple list of the 10 best comforters available on the online retailer. Okay, now you can click "add to cart."

Down Alternative Comforter
Utopia Bedding Down Alternative Comforter $30 $27

This alternative down comforter is meant to keep you cozy throughout all four seasons. It's made with soft material and designed with box-style stitching for a clean, classic look. Plus, it's machine washable for easy maintenance. Of the nearly 3,000 reviews the comforter has garnered on Amazon, the majority are overwhelmingly positive. Users applaud it for being fluffy but not too hot for summer, nor too thin for the winter.

Down Alternative Comforter
AmazonBasics Down Alternative Comforter $33 $30

The recipient of an "Amazon's Choice" banner, this comforter is an affordable option made of 100 percent polyester with a microfiber shell. It's far cheaper than most down comforters and is less likely to trigger allergies than down-feather options.

Down Alternative Comforter
Superior Down Alternative Comforter $52

With a medium-weight filling, this comforter is ideal for year-round temperatures. It's a hypoallergenic choice made of breathable material. According to customer reviews, it scores high on softness, comfort, durability, and how easy it is to clean.

Down Alternative
Buffy Down Alternative Comforter $150

This comforter from Buffy comes in at a higher price point, but according to the reviews, it's well worth the cost. Eucalyptus fibers allow for 10 times less water to be used during production, which is better for the planet, but it also gives the comforter its light and fluffy weight. Win-win! It's also made of 100 percent recycled BPA-free bottles so you can feel good about your purchase and its effect on the environment.

White Quilted Comforter
Equinox International All-Season White Quilted Comforter $40 $27

A goose down alternative comforter, this piece is thought to be suitable for people with sensitive skin thanks to its soft microfiber cover. You can use it as a duvet insert or simply as a comforter on its own for a minimalist look. It's racked up almost 3,000 reviews on Amazon.

Goose Down Alternative Quilted Comforter
Hospitology Prodcuts Microfiber All-Season Goose Down Alternative Quilted Comforter $40

This goose down alternative comforter is hypoallergenic and machine washable. It feels like cotton although it's made of 100 percent polyester which is ideal for those prone to allergies. Additionally, the shell fabric is equipped with stain repellent technology to help you keep your comforter clean and like new. Owners say it's lightweight and ideal for summer although it could keep you warm year-round.

Down Comforter Duvet Insert
Egyptian Bedding Siberian Goose Down Comforter Duvet Inser $130

If you're looking for plushy luxury, this is the best comforter around. The cover is made of 1200 thread count 100 percent Egyptian cotton and filled with goose down. It even features gold rope piping for a small, chic touch.

White Down Alternative Comforter Duvet Insert
KingLinen White Down Alternative Comforter Duvet Insert King $40

A simple, no-frills comforter, this one is made of hypoallergenic poly fiberfill and is machine washable. With more than 4,400 reviews on Amazon, it's a top choice. Customers agree that it's a high-quality comforter, especially for the reasonable price.

Down Alternative Duvet Insert
TEKAMON Down Alternative Duvet Insert $40

Designed for year-round, all-season comfort, this duvet insert is soft and breathable, with an allergy-friendly polyfill. It even comes with a 100 percent satisfaction guarantee so you can easily return it if you're not happy once it arrives. Customers note that it's thick and plush, yet it breathes well so you won't get too hot.

Down Alternative Quilted Comforter
Linenspa All-Season White Down Alternative Quilted Comforter $30

This comforter has it all. It's machine washable, dryer safe, hypoallergenic, and reversible. Of the more than 9,400 reviews on Amazon, a majority are wildly positive, garnering the product 4.3 out of 5 stars and a #1 Best Seller seal of approval.

Related Stories