The 5 Best Rums for Piña Coladas (and How to Make One)

Updated 11/09/18
best rum for pina coladas
Gräfe & Unzer Verlag/Stockfood

Irresistibly refreshing and naturally derived, the piña colada is the perfect drink to sip on a beach, to batch up for friends, or to change up your standard happy hour regimen. While we may be on the opposite side of the calendar from National Piña Colada Day, there’s never a wrong time to enjoy a well-made piña colada. The creamy combination of rum, coconut cream, fresh pineapple juice, and crushed ice is an irresistible treat that couldn't be easier to make. 

One of Puerto Rico’s most loved exports, this classic cocktail should be crafted with only the freshest ingredients—and, of course, the perfect rum. Typically made from distilling the fermented juice of sugar cane, sugar cane syrup, and sugar cane molasse, it's a liquor like no other.

Most agree that aged rum is finer than fresh, as the distilled beverage is usually aged in the same oak barrels that previously held whiskey or bourbon. However, which rum is best is really up to your personal tastes. For example, for the lightest rums, you'll want something from the Caribbean, while a rum that most closely resembles vodka will be found in a product of Puerto Rico. Read on to discover a few of the best rums for piña coladas.

Bacardí Silver

Barcardí Superior $10
Shop

You’ll be hard-pressed to find a more versatile, cost-effective, and cocktail-ready rum for piña coladas. But it’s not just Bacardí’s smoothness (or price point) that we love. This ultra-drinkable rum has just the right sweetness and flavor to stand up to fruit flavors without overpowering them.

Enameled Bar Tool Set
Williams Sonoma Enameled Bar Tool Set $50 $25
Shop

El Dorado 3-Year Rum

El Dorado White Rum $25
Shop

This smooth and well-rounded cask-aged rum is one of the best rums for piña coladas. A favorite among bartenders and classic cocktail enthusiasts, El Dorado is defined by hints of citrus, coconut, and vanilla.

Canvas Home Dauville Collection Set Of 4 Coasters
Canvas Home Dauville Collection Set of 4 Coasters $46
Shop

Wray and Nephew

Wray & Nephew White Rum $23
Shop

This delectable white overproof rum is the perfect pick for those who crave a serious cocktail in the form of a tropical treat. Strong enough to taste the alcohol yet smooth enough to make for a fabulous blended cocktail, this retro Jamaican rum boasts a fruity aroma and signature molasses undertones, making it one of the best rums for piña coladas.

Smeg '50S Retro Style Blender
Smeg '50S Retro Style Blender $250
Shop

Bacardí Pineapple

Bacardí Pineapple Fusion Rum $11
Shop

In the event that the original recipe is not enough pineapple for you, it’s perfectly acceptable to double down with this extra fruit-forward, ultra-pineapple variation. What we love most about Bacardí Pineapple is its natural pineapple flavor, which is pronounced but not overwhelming.

Nordstrom 5-Piece Stainless Steel Bar Tool Set
Nordstrom at Home 5-Piece Stainless Steel Bar Tool Set $69
Shop

Yolo Silver

Yolo Rum $17
Shop

Developed by the same iconic master distiller behind rums like Caña Brava and SelvaRey, Yolo is as well-balanced and expertly designed as it is approachable. This piña colada–ready rum is sustainably crafted in Colorado with old-school Panamanian origins and is well worth giving a try.

Nordstrom At Home Recipe Cocktail Shaker
Nordstrom at Home Recipe Cocktail Shaker $39
Shop

How to Make It

With a few of the best rums for piña coladas under your belt, here’s how to make one:

Ingredients:

2 oz. rum
1 oz. coconut cream
6 oz. fresh pineapple juice
1/2 cup crushed ice

2 oz. rum
1 oz. coconut cream
6 oz. fresh pineapple juice
1/2 cup crushed ice

Directions:

Blend all ingredients thoroughly, and then serve with pineapple and cherry garnish in a hurricane or collins glass. (Bonus points for serving in a hollowed-out pineapple.)

Now that you know some of the best rums for piña coladas, it’s time to further your know-how.

Up next: discover the best rum for mojitos.

Related Stories