The 4 Best Bourbon Whiskeys for an Old Fashioned

Updated 09/26/19

tusumaru/Getty Images. Graphic by Cristina Cianci

Few other quaffs have made a bigger impact on craft-cocktail culture than the Old Fashioned. Its creation dates back to 1880, when a bartender at The Pendennis Club, a private social club in Louisville, Kentucky, first invented the drink. Later that year, the recipe was brought to New York City's Waldorf-Astoria Hotel bar by one of the club's venerated members, Colonel James E. Pepper, a master bourbon distiller and industrialist. The rest is, as they say, history.

Perhaps due to its reverence in American culture, the cocktail—traditionally composed of bourbon or rye, just a bit of sugar and bitters, and a fresh orange peel to garnish—is now a drink staple on virtually every awesome cocktail menu there is. But while its recipe may be simple, choosing a whiskey that best offsets the cocktail's bittersweet flavors can be a bit more complex.

Whether you’re a budding bartender or a classic-cocktail enthusiast, here are four of the best Old Fashioned bourbons—plus one rye whiskey—that professional mixologists swear by, plus six cocktail essentials, and a classic Old Fashioned recipe that's super-easy to master. Cheers!

Sweet and Affordable

A bottle of Buffalo Trace Bourbon with a green foil top.
Buffalo Trace Kentucky Straight Bourbon $25
Shop

A perennial darling of the craft-cocktail set, Buffalo Trace is the go-to bourbon for a classic Old Fashioned. With a hint of candy-sweetness and an expertly balanced blend of corn, rye, and barley malt, Buffalo Trace lets the fundamental elements of the cocktail shine. If you’re planning a dinner party or restocking the liquor cabinet, this is also one of the most drinkable and affordable whiskeys to keep on hand. “You’d be hard-pressed to find something this good for under $30,” says Theo Lieberman, head sommelier of New York City's La Compagnie des Vins Surnaturels restaurant.

Set of four glasses with gold tone beehive pattern on their bottom halves, along with a matching crystal decanter.
Fitz + Floyd Daphne 5-Piece Whiskey Set $37
Shop

Thick and Full-Bodied

A bottle of whiskey with a silver top and label.
Eagle Rare 10-Year Bourbon $55
Shop

Featuring notes of molasses, maple, and vanilla, Eagle Rare is the bourbon of choice for Old Fashioneds served by some of New York City's most influential cocktail bars, like The Richardson and Death & Co. “In an Old Fashioned, balance manifests in a different way than in a Whiskey Sour," notes David Kaplan, founder of Death & Co. "It’s all about enhancing the flavor of the base spirit while rounding off its edges." If you're looking for a sultry-sweet Old Fashioned, this is your bourbon of choice.

A set of four white coasters standing upright on a gold tone stand.
Rabbit 5-Piece Coaster and Stand Set $40
Shop

Strong and Woodsy

A bottle of Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon.
Woodford Reserve Double Oaked Bourbon $48
Shop

Richer and heftier than traditional whiskeys, Woodford Reserve Double Oaked bourbon carries distinctive notes of caramel, oak, and hazelnut that make for a strong, woodsy Old Fashioned.

Set of two crystal old fashioned glasses.
Waterford Set of 2 Lismore Connoisseur Whiskey Straight Sided Tumbler Glasses $100
Shop

Salty, Mineral Finish

A bottle of Mulholland American Whiskey.
Mulholland American Whiskey $30
Shop

Mulholland American Whiskey is a bourbon that's steadily gaining a following among craft-cocktail aficionados: It's an affordable, higher-proof alternative to more established brands. Mullholland makes “a distinctive West Coast Old Fashioned,” says Joshua Bermudez, head bartender at The Wellesbourne bar in Los Angeles. “Its clean, sea salt–mineral finish stands up gorgeously to the sweeter elements of the cocktail.”

A glass with a silicone insert that freezes ice for only half the glass.
Corkcicle Whiskey Wedge $18
Shop

Smooth and Peppery

A bottle of Rittenhouse Rye 100 whiskey with a black top and label.
Rittenhouse Rye 100 $22
Shop

Is bourbon not your thing? Opt for a classic, rye-whiskey Old Fashioned. (Heck, if it's good enough for Mad Men's Don Draper, it's good enough for us). Don't let its 100-proof status fool you into thinking you can't handle it: A Rittenhouse-based Old Fashioned is supremely smooth, spicy, and slightly sweet, with its natural notes of black pepper, stone fruit, and spice.

Whiskey being poured into a glass with a large soapstone sphere inside.
SPARQ Home Set of 2 Whiskey Spheres $20
Shop

How to Make an Old Fashioned

Now that you're clued into which bourbons and rye whiskeys make the best Old Fashioned cocktails, be your own bartender and serve 'em up like a pro.

Ingredients:

2 oz. bourbon or rye whiskey
1 sugar cube (or 1/2 tsp. sugar)
2 to 3 dashes of Angostura bitters
1 orange peel

Directions:

  • Add whiskey, sugar cube, bitters, and a large ice cube to a mixing glass. Stir with a cocktail mixing spoon to break up the sugar, or for 10 to 15 seconds.
  • With a Hawthorne strainer, strain contents into a double old fashioned glass pre-filled with a large ice cube or whiskey stone.
  • Slide the orange peel around the rim of the glass and then toss it in as a garnish.
A wooden box beside a pair of tongs, two whiskey glasses, and two metal whiskey stones.
Atterstone Essential Whiskey Box Set $60
Shop

Related Stories