Big-Batch Halloween Cocktails That are Festive Without Being Too Much

Updated 10/18/19

How Sweet Eats

Truly exceptional Halloween cocktails do a few things. First, they’re delicious enough to keep party guests coming back for refills all night long. (That’s a given.) Second, they’re festive enough to reference the holiday—without getting too on-the-nose. Third, they’re low-maintenance enough to liberate the host from their duties, for at least a little while. No one wants to spend the entirety of a party restocking the bar. It’s vital that party cocktails are adequately low-effort, so that hosts can spend more time sipping cocktails than they did whipping them up. 

Prepping a big-batch cocktail means you won't spend the whole party measuring, mixing, and serving drinks.

This formula for crafting perfect Halloween cocktails sounds pretty straightforward. But digging up recipes that fit the bill—in this case, all three bills—can prove a little challenging. Big-batch fall cocktails abound. So do decidedly spooky Halloween cocktails. But blend the two together—and sprinkle in some aesthetic sophistication—and you’ve got a rare triple threat on your hands. Libations that incredible are hard to come by. (A fact that’s perhaps more frightening than any horror film you’ve watched this month.)

Though these truly superb, big-batch Halloween cocktails are (unfortunately) hard to come by, we (fortunately) know where to look. We’ve sifted through the internet’s vast array of Halloween-themed drinks and unearthed only those that are delicious, low-effort, and spooky-sophisticated. No fake eyeballs or complicated small-batch recipes here. Just festive Halloween punches you can make once and drink all night long.

01 of 06

Pumpkin Patch Punch

halloween punch

Half Baked Harvest

The Recipe: Pumpkin Patch Punch

The Hero Ingredient: Spiced pumpkin butter leaves this cocktail feeling (and tasting) next-level seasonal.

Pro Tip: Coat the rims of your cocktail glasses in cinnamon sugar, rather than just sugar. The extra dose of spice will render this delightful cocktail even more autumnal than it already is.

Why We Love It: Everything about this punch—from its appearance to its flavor blend—feels fall-appropriate. Plus, the pumpkin motif is Halloween-friendly without being Halloween-exclusive. If you love the drink, you can continue serving it well into November. (Pumpkins are Thanksgiving-friendly too, after all.)

02 of 06

Apple, Pumpkin, Beer Cocktails

halloween cocktail

Cooking and Beer

The Hero Ingredient: Beer? In cocktails? The idea may sound blasphemous, but these cocktails prove it can work. Pumpkin Ale lends this big-batch punch a little fall spirit—and it pairs magnificently with the apple cider, lemon juice, and bourbon the rest of the recipe calls for.

Pro Tip: The recipe suggests dropping cinnamon sticks and cranberries in each glass, but we suspect this cocktail would look just as good sans garnish. The addition of beer offers enough low-maintenance appeal on its own—no décor needed.

Why We Love It: Cocktails can get seriously heavy and seriously sugary. But this punch offers a more casual take on the fall cocktail, and is worth enjoying even when you’re not hosting a party.

03 of 06

Apple Cider Punch

halloween punch

How Sweet Eats

The Recipe: Apple Cider Punch

The Hero Ingredient: Aperol seems like a decidedly warm-weather ingredient. (Peak aperol spritz season is summer, after all.) But this punch repurposes it in a fall-friendly way.

Pro Tip: Since this punch is low on alcohol, it’s perfect for serving at all kinds of events—slightly buzzed brunches, afternoon book clubs, and more. Because sometimes you want to enjoy a cocktail without getting too tipsy, and this drink is made for those days.

Why We Love It: Fall flavors tend to get really heavy and indulgent, but this party punch keeps everything light. Prosecco, pomegranate cider, ginger beer, and chilled apple cider combine to create a very drinkable cocktail—and one you can sip all night without getting terribly drunk.

04 of 06

Sparkling Pomegranate Cider Punch

fall punch

How Sweet Eats

The Hero Ingredient: Homemade autumn simple syrup will add spicy depth to this already-delicious fall cocktail. (Don’t fret—the recipe teaches you exactly how to make it. So you can whip up a batch with ease, and then brag to all your friends about how you make your own simple syrups now.)

Pro Tip: The recipe calls for either ginger ale or ginger beer. While the choice is ultimately yours, we recommend using ginger ale to create a more casual, day drink-friendly cocktail, and opting for ginger beer when hosting a nighttime event. The former will feel a little more low-maintenance, while the latter will feel veritably bar-worthy.

Why We Love It: Instead of sticking to one or two autumn flavors, this cocktail combines a whole bunch of them. Apple, cinnamon, pomegranate, ginger, and orange rind in the same drink? Yes, please.

05 of 06

Spiced Wine

spiced wine

Well Plated

The Recipe: Spiced Wine from Well Plated

The Hero Ingredient: Brandy will take your wine-based drink and add all kinds of sweet, rich depth. Because sometimes it isn’t enough to combine wine and apple juice and all your favorite spices—you need something stronger to round out the flavor blend (and to up the ABV a tad).

Pro Tip: When selecting the red wine to use as your base, you’ll want to opt for something bold but not overwhelming—fruity but not too sweet. Lighter-bodied reds, like pinot noir, may prove too low-key. Medium-bodied reds—like merlots and zinfandels—may prove a better pick.

Why We Love It: Spiced wine is an autumn favorite, making it a no-fail addition to any party you throw this season. Plus, it’s low-maintenance—just throw your ingredients into a slow cooker, and pop it open once the party starts.

06 of 06

Slow Cooker Caramel Apple Cider Cocktail

slow cooker cocktail

Pizzazzerie

The Hero Ingredient: Instead of calling for simple syrup or some kind of sugary juice, this recipe gets right to the point: It asks you to dump 1/4 cup of brown sugar straight into your slow cooker. Normally, this would result in a cocktail that’s hyper-sweet. But since the sugar will have time to cook in your Crockpot, you’ll end up with something that’s a little richer, deeper, and more indulgent.

Pro Tip: Fans of spice might consider throwing in a little extra cinnamon, a few more cloves, or a few fall flavors the recipe doesn’t call for. (Nutmeg, anyone?) The heaping dose of caramel syrup and brown sugar may leave the cider tasting perfectly sweet for some and too sweet for others—the additional spices may even things out a bit for those who find themselves in the latter category.

Why We Love It: Caramel and apples are a match made in flavor heaven. Throw in a little alcohol, and you’ve got a veritable triple threat (albeit a sugary-sweet one).

Related Stories