6 Ways to Choose a Bottle of Wine That Will Wow at Your Next Holiday Party

Updated 11/19/19

Lumina/Stocksy

Break out the bubbly: The holiday season is officially here. Whether you’re attending a holiday-themed housewarming, a big New Years Eve bash, or simply going over to your bestie's house to watch Love Actually for the umpteenth time, there’s no better way to kick off the holiday season than with a great bottle of wine.

However, buying a bottle of wine that will impress your host and the rest of the crowd is hard. With so many brands, blends, and price points to choose from, there’s simply too many options. And just because you picked up a bottle that has a pretty label doesn’t mean it’ll actually be good. 

“Today there is so much information available via various publications and the internet it can be hard to know who to trust to direct you to a wine you’ll enjoy,” adds Vanessa Conlin, head of wine at Wine Access. 

Don’t worry, we’re here to help. Below, we’re sharing expert-approved ways to buy a bottle that will make you the life of the party. 

Measure Up

Whoever says the biggest things come in small packages has clearly never received an extra-large bottle of wine. If you want to get the party started, go big with a supersized bottle. 

“One of the easiest ways to wow a party is to show up with a large format bottle of wine—a magnum or double-magnum instantly makes any gathering a party,” Conlin says. "Everyone remembers fondly the person that showed up with a giant bottle of wine.”

Trust us, the host will thank you for not having to uncork a new bottle every hour. 

Keep it Versatile 

We hate to be the bearer of bad news, but buying wine is not a one-blend-fits-all situation. (After all, there’s a reason wine pairings exist.) But if you’re on the hunt for something versatile that will pair well with multiple dishes, Pinot Noir is the way to go. 

“Pinot Noir is a Thanksgiving favorite because it’s well balanced and fruit-forward, pairing well with staples like turkey, stuffing, mashed potatoes, and cranberry sauce,” Joel Caruso, Vivino Partner Sommelier.

Depending on your social calendar, you might want to stock up on bottles of Pinot Noir now so you’ll always be ready with a present. Just make sure you know how to store ‘em.

Embrace Bubbles 

It doesn’t matter if you prefer red, white, or rosé: Everyone can appreciate a great of bubbly 

When choosing wine for a holiday party, don’t forget the bubbles,” Conlin says.

Fortunately, you don’t have to spend the big bucks on a bottle of fancy Champagne to impress your host. 

“Champagne is always a hit, but for the budget conscious consumer there is a variety of alternatives that are more affordable—from Cava and French Cremant to Prosecco—that will liven up the party at a fraction of the price,” she says. 

Know the Story 

Everything has a story—and a great bottle of wine is no exception. According to Conlin, knowing the story behind a bottle can turn most options into a wondrous gift. 

“Bringing a bottle that is meaningful is a great way to wow a party,” she says. 

Whether you ask your local wine shop for some more information or search a varietal online, research makes it possible to fake your way to wine expert status. 

“Wine is about more than drinking, its true power comes from being able to transport you to a different time and place,” she explains. “Sharing the story of the producer, region, or just recalling a special moment in your life when you had the wine is an easy way to wow a party and make an impression.” 

Wine is about more than drinking, its true power comes from being able to transport you to a different time and place. Sharing the story of the producer, region, or just recalling a special moment in your life when you had the wine is an easy way to wow a party and make an impression.

Try Lesser-Known Regions 

Let’s be honest, we all have those friends who fancy themselves certified oenophiles. They know the difference between merlot and Pinot noir, plus they can detect every last note and nuance of a glass. Unless you interrogated your local wine shop’s sales assistant, finding a bottle that will wow them is easier said than done.

According to Caruso, it pays to go off the beaten path. 

“Explore lesser-known regions and styles you may not be familiar with,” he says. “You can get great value wines from places like Paso Robles in California, Puglia in Italy, Portugal and South Africa as a few examples. 

Want to impress with a French wine? Caruso encourages you to consider wines from Beaujolais made from Gamay or Provence for rosé. Trust us, even the snobbiest of wine snobs will give you some kudos for your creative purchase. 

Share Your Fave 

You don’t have to be a sommelier to know a great bottle of wine when you taste it. If you’re stumped on picking out a wine that will wow, why not share one of your favorite blends?

“The biggest mistake I see people make is not trusting their own palate when selecting a wine,” Conlin. “Often people buy wine based on scores alone, without stopping to consider if it’s a style of wine they would enjoy.”

Ultimately, the holiday season is all about giving, and your host will he touched to receive a bottle that means so much to you. 

Related Stories