The Best New York City Hotels Under $200 a Night

"New York City" and "budget" are words that just don't seem to go together in a sentence. Almost every activity in the city comes at a price. Between the boutique shopping, world-class restaurants, buzzing rooftop bars, and once-in-a-lifetime Broadway shows, it's easy to rack up a tab faster than you can hail one of those iconic yellow cabs. Luckily we're here to tell you that if you'd rather spend less money on accommodations so you can dedicate more funds to actually seeing the city, there are options.

Contrary to popular belief, New York City is home to a host of hotels that offer plush beds and great amenities for less than $200 a night—you just have to know where to look. What these rooms lack in square footage they make up for in design: Honorable mentions go to the new Freehand Hotel, a Roman and Williams–designed hotel that offers dorm-style rooms, and The Jane Hotel, a West Village establishment with a thriving bar scene. Pack your bags: These are the best New York City hotels under $200.

Arlo SoHo

a room at Arlo SoHo
Image by Arlo  

Located in bustling Hudson Square and nestled between hot neighborhoods TriBeCa and SoHo, Arlo is currently one of the hottest new hotels in the big city. Boasting an open-air rooftop bar with one of the best views of Manhattan, it also has a trendy 24-hour bodega carrying artisanal goods for all your last-minute needs. Expect handsome walnut beds with smart mid-century details throughout the rooms, and enjoy tasty Southern cuisine at the on-site restaurant. There's a focus on local amenities, offering guests free classes at nearby fitness spots.

Neighborhood: SoHo

Rates: From $108/night

Lunya Washable Silk Sleep Mask
Lunya Washable Silk Sleep Mask $48

The Jane Hotel

a room at The Jane Hotel
The Jane Hotel

The Jane Hotel, a century-old West Village landmark from buzzworthy hoteliers Sean MacPherson and Eric Goode, sits on the edge of the Meatpacking District, only six blocks from the High Line. Formerly a lodging for sailors, the hip budget hotel has nautically themed accents and throwback turn-of-the-century touches. The hotel's French-Moroccan restaurant, Café Gitane, is not to be missed, and if you're in the city to eat and drink, you're in the right neighborhood.

Neighborhood: TriBeCa

Rates: From $69/night

Williams Sonoma Chambers(R) Classic Robe
Williams Sonoma Chambers Classic Robe $99 $74

Tillary Hotel

a room at the Tillary Hotel
Courtesy of Tillary Hotel

Downtown Brooklyn's first boutique hotel, Tillary Hotel, is just steps from the Brooklyn Bridge—your perfect intro to the borough and close to hip neighborhoods like DUMBO, Brooklyn Heights, and Fort Greene. Intimate with modern, graphic rooms, the interiors have midcentury modern touches and masculine heather-gray tones. The beer garden is a bonus.

Neighborhood: Downtown Brooklyn

Rates: From $109/night

Susanne Kaufmann Mallow Blossom Bubble Bath
Susanne Kaufmann Mallow Blossom Bubble Bath $70

HGU Hotel

a room at HGU Hotel
HGU Hotel

A relative newcomer to the Manhattan hotel scene, HGU Hotel is centrally located for business travelers but designed with the comforts of home. The rooms are surprisingly spacious by New York standards, and a renovation means the white subway tiled–bathrooms are squeaky-clean.

Neighborhood: NoMad

Rates: From approximately $116/night

Muji Linen Muji slippers
Muji Linen Twill Slippers $15

Freehand Hotel

a room at the Freehand Hotel
Freehand New York

Freehand Hotel is causing a serious buzz for good reason: The Roman and Williams-designed hotel offers a ton of lodging options, from bunk bed dorms to apartment-style suites. You'll also want to spend time on the rooftop, which has stellar city views and great cocktails. 

Neighborhood: Gramercy

Rates: From approximately $113/night

DWR Aerocotton Towel
Design Within Reach Aerocotton Towel Set $65

The Time New York

a room at The Time Hotel
The Time New York

If you're planning to see a Broadway show during your trip to the Big Apple or are visiting for business in Midtown, The Time New York is a great choice. Renovated by David Rockwell with high-tech amenities, the hotel is in the heart of the Theater District and Times Square. We love its modernist interiors with industrial accents, cool color palettes, and pops of metal. We've also heard great things about its cocktail bar, LeGrande Lounge. Guests also have access to the nearby Equinox gym, if you're keen on staying fit.

Neighborhood: The Theater District

Rates: From $143/night

Snowe Percale Pillow Cases
Snowe Percale Pillow Cases $60

Orchard Street Hotel

a room at the Orchard Street Hotel
Orchard Street Hotel

For those who plan to shop their hearts out and sample downtown's endless nightlife options, but require the fuss and amenities of a major hotel, newcomer Orchard Street Hotel is an affordable, straightforward option. Guest rooms are stark white, airy, and loft-like with stunning views—they have everything you need, but not much more. The hotel doesn't have a restaurant on-site, but there are plenty of awesome dining options nearby, and while there's no gym to speak of, guests get access to Ludlow Fitness nearby.

Neighborhood: The Lower East Side

Rates: From $122/night

Marzotto Group Serena Throw
Marzotto Group Serena Throw $195 $146

The Paper Factory Hotel

a room at The Paper Factory hotel
Paper Factory Hotel

Built in a century-old paper warehouse, The Paper Factory Hotel in Long Island City takes its aesthetic inspiration from the building's history with an old paper machine transformed into a restaurant/bar, a spiral staircase made out of a tower of books, and countless other repurposed design elements. With 12-foot ceilings, expansive windows, and spacious rooms, the hotel offers the best elements of the industrial loft style.

Neighborhood: Long Island City

Rates: From $89/night

vintage pajama set
J.Crew Vintage Short-Sleeve Pajama Set $85

Yotel New York

a room at Yotel
Yotel New York

If Virgin America let you stay the night, the experience might feel something like a stay at Yotel New York. With futuristic architecture and interior design, and mood purple lighting, this Midtown West hotel has been aptly described as "Jetsons" meets "Vanilla Sky." The interiors are, in fact, inspired by first-class airplane cabins and Japan's pod hotels. Meanwhile, the hotel's rooftop bar, Asian fusion restaurant, Saturday night DJ dance party, on-site yoga studio, and movie screening room are all worthy attractions.

Neighborhood: Midtown West

Rates: From $104/night

Design Within Reach City Hall Alarm Clock
Arne Jacobsen City Hall Alarm Clock $129

Duane Street Hotel

a room at the Duane Street Hotel
Courtesy of Duane Street Hotel

Looking for a relaxed vibe and want to steer clear of scene-y hotels? TriBeCa's Duane Street Hotel is a quiet spot that's also business-friendly with free Wi-Fi and a communal table in the lobby. The interiors have a bit of a bachelor-pad vibe, with leather headboards and midcentury-inspired furniture. Other perks: It's pet-friendly, and guests get free passes to the nearby Equinox gym.

Neighborhood: TriBeCa

Rates: From $143/night

Sunday Morning Gold Travel Candle
Brooklyn Candle Studio Sunday Morning Travel Candle $16

Nu Hotel Brooklyn

a room at the Nu Hotel
Courtesy of Nu Hotel

Displaying what we like to call "affordable luxury," Brooklyn's Nu Hotel is perfect for artsy types, with quirky modern interiors: Think recycled wood, eco-friendly materials, vintage letters, custom hammocks in suites, and rotating murals by local artists. The hotel also has a state-of-the-art 24/7 fitness center, free bikes, and a great sidewalk café and bar with top-notch cocktails and tapas.

Neighborhood: Brooklyn

Rates: From $110/night

Slip Embroidered Silk Queen Pillowcase
Slip Mulberry Silk Queen Pillowcase $90

Pick up a copy of The Fashion Insider's Guide to New York ($19) for more chic suggestions.

Related Stories