Under-$50 NYC Tasting Menu to Try in New York City

Updated 04/22/19

Eleven Madison Park, Per Se, Jean Georges: New York City is home to some of the world's best restaurants—and the most expensive too. A tasting menu at the newly revamped Eleven Madison Park, voted 2017's best restaurant in the world, will set you back $315 a person—and that's without a drop of alcohol. Even just an hour at the mysterious Threesome Tollbooth, a three-seat speakeasy in Bushwick, will run you $120 per person per hour. Yes, when it comes to footing the bill, New York City is not for the faint of heart.

But fear not, spring chickens, the affordable (and delicious) tasting menus of your wildest Valentine's evening dreams are also attainable in the city that never sleeps. That is if you know where to look. Ahead, our favorite under-$50 tasting menus in NYC, from East Village to Brooklyn, will leave you satiated and just a little richer. Trust us, these under-the-radar chef tastings are worth the trek.

The Saint Austere

The Saint Austere Tasting Menu
Courtesy of The Saint Austere

The Deal: $50 Chef's Tasting, four courses

The Setting: Golden-era hip-hop and a four-course chef's tasting await in the dimly lit dining room of Brooklyn's The Saint Austere. This family restaurant is known for its unpretentious Italian fare filled with the freshest ingredients. The European-focused wine list highlights family-owned estates, so you'll want to save a little extra for libations.

The Neighborhood: Williamsburg

Sugarfish

Sugarfish Tasting Menu
Courtesy of Sugarfish

The Deal: $39 Trust Me Menu, nine courses

The Setting: Finally, Los Angeles's most coveted sushi made its way eastward to New York City, and the prices are more than reasonable. The one caveat is Sugarfish doesn't take reservations, and the wait can be long, so head over early with a solid plan for pre-dinner cocktails to kill time. A mouthwatering nine-course omakase awaits on the other side for a mere $39 a person. Your patience will pay off.

The Neighborhood: Flatiron

Atoboy

Atoboy Tasting Menu
Courtesy of Atoboy

The Deal: $42 Dinner Menu, three courses

The Setting: Atoboy, the beloved Korean restaurant in NoMad, charmed the hearts of the most discerning food critics with one simple offering: a selection of Korean-inspired small plates and rice for $42. The famed New York Times critic Pete Wells recommends a selection of lotus root, black sea bass, beef tartare, sunchoke, mackerel, pork jowl, with a panna cotta and sujeonggwa granita for dessert.

The Neighborhood: NoMad

Autre Kyo Ya

Autre Kyo Ya Tasting Menu
Courtesy of Autre Kyo Ya

The Deal: $50 Chef Course, five courses

The Setting: Curious to know what French-Japanese cuisine tastes like? Head over to East Village's Autre Kyo Ya, the sister restaurant of Michelin-starred Kyo Ya. During the months of January and February only, its Chef Course (normally $80), is down to $50 per person. So brave the cold, and enjoy your selection of onion cream soup, Alaskan king crab, sweet potato tempura, monkfish bouillabaisse, roasted organic chicken, and caramelized clementine.

The Neighborhood: East Village

Sushi Katsuei

Sushi Katsuei
Courtesy of Sushi Katsuei

The Deal: $45 Omakase, nine courses

The Setting: It's an all-too-well-kept secret: Sushi Katsuei serves up some of the best sushi in Brooklyn. The omakase at its Park Slope location starts at only $45 and will leave you satiated, happy, and relieved that your check boasted one less "0" than New York's most expensive omakase at Masa, which clocks in at $450 per person.

The Neighborhood: Park Slope

Pig and Khao

Pig & Khao Tasting Menu
Courtesy of Pig and Khao

The Deal: $45 Chef's Course Tasting Menu, five courses

The Setting: Available Sunday through Thursday, Pig and Khao delivers on the promise of a South Asian–inspired, five-course tasting menu with Thai and Filipino influences, which you can wash down with its "self-serve" bottomless draft of Narragansett (or a selection of craft cocktails, if that's more your speed).

The Neighborhood: Lower East Side

Related Stories