Here's What Happened When I Quit Sugar for an Entire Year

Casey Vassallo
Casey Vassallo

New Year resolutions are, more often than not, clichés. We set broad, typically aspirational and unmeasurable goals. Most entail money, work, travel, or health. To go on that holiday, get a raise, get fitter. If anything, it’s more of a conversation starter around the New Year's threshold, similar to "How are you?" and weather chat. In all honesty, I don’t remember ever setting any resolution-style goals until 2016.

Back when my then-boyfriend—now fiancé—and I moved in together, we seemed to have a little thing for bacon. I know—processed meat —not great. We didn’t think so either, and decided to avoid it for a year in the hope we’d ditch the bad habit. For good measure, we threw in soft drinks. Full disclosure: Alcoholic beverages didn’t count.

The year 2016 came to a close and we’d managed to do it. But before the year rounded out, I decided to set myself a new goal: No fast food in 2017. For me, that meant none of the obvious chains, from McDonald's to Grill’d. Rather than make it impossible, I’d allow myself the occasional late night falafel kebab from an independent. Suffice it to say, I stuck to that one too.

For 2018, I felt I should go bigger. Refined sugar big. Like the years before, I’d developed a few bad habits. I was having peanut M&Ms with my tea, snacking on packets of Iced VoVos, and indulging in a scoop of Gelato Messina’s Pistachio Praline with a girlfriend whenever we caught up (too often). So I quit it to kick the sugar fixes. (Again, full disclosure: Alcohol didn’t count.) Here’s what happened.

IT'S IN EVERYTHING

I was taken aback by just how much sugar I was consuming in general, despite considering myself a healthy person. I rarely eat meat, avoid dairy, and cook well. It only became apparent how wrong I was after I started to closely examine the products I thought were safe. Disregarding the nutrition label (where it breaks down grams per serving), I looked straight to the ingredient listing. The devil is in that detail, sugar being the item consistently listed near to the top. Ingredients are listed in order of quantity and sugar is often second or third on most. Wholemeal wraps, muesli, and cocoa-heavy chocolate from health food stores were swiftly off my menu.

When it’s in everything, even in small doses, it adds up, according to Advanced Accredited Practising Dietician Melanie McGrice. “When you’re getting those little bits in a whole range of different foods each day, like a little bit in tomato sauce, your breakfast cereal, your salad dressing,” she explains, “that can all really add up to be quite a few excess kilojoules that you probably wouldn’t be consuming if you were making your food from scratch.” 

That’s where the term "whole food" comes from. There’s been little, if any, processing of the food so it’s free from unnecessary stuff. Making a pasta sauce using organic tinned tomatoes, fresh chopped garlic, basil, oregano, and onion is therefore free from what you’d normally find in something pre-bought. Let’s just say the weekly grocery shop was painfully long to begin with. I had to read the back of everything. Like most things, though, the longer you do it, the easier it gets. I avoided that aisle and committed to memory the items free-from sugar.

THE SWEET FACTS

There’s a difference between refined sugar (sucrose), and the naturally-occurring sugar we get from fruit (fructose) and dairy (lactose). “When we’re talking about refined sugar, its excess kilojoules without providing any nutrition,” McGrice explains. Aside the obvious facts, like it being a great attraction for bacteria in your mouth, it simply has no benefit. It’s also worth mentioning that when refined sugar is removed, many add in artificial or alternative sweeteners, some of which aren't much healthier. So while stevia and date syrup may not be quite as unhealthy as refined sugar, they still have their drawbacks.

THE BENEFITS

By cutting out sugar, McGrice says most can expect to see an improvement in complexion, energy, your mood, and maybe even lose a couple of kilos. In extreme cases, quitting sugar can mean a decrease in inflammation or joint issues, too.

For me, my skin has been all over the place this year, which I put down to quitting sugar but also getting off the pill (thanks, hormones). But I have more energy, and in turn do more exercise, which has helped me break up with a little stubborn weight I’ve been carrying around.

Now, if I eat something a little naughty, I can immediately feel it. I asked McGrice: When I’m out and have a burger, for example, am I feeling nauseous after it because there’s hidden sugar in it? The answer was new information to me. “Your foods that have more refined sugar in them tend to be more highly processed, and have more saturated fat and salt as well, so when you’re decreasing refined sugar in your diet, you tend to be making a lot of other dietary improvements, as well.” It’s obvious, but I didn’t even consider the run-on effect quitting refined sugar would have. Because the two go hand-in-hand, almost always, I ended up avoiding more of the bad stuff inadvertently.

Throughout the year, the cravings decreased, and naturally sweet things and raw treats were enough to placate my desire for sugar. Then there’s the actual matter of taste. When eating those healthier alternatives, less was more. “That’s when you really know you’ve made changes—when your palate changes,” McGrice explains. “When you have something and you go, ‘Oh my goodness, that is so sweet, how did I drink or eat that before?’”

HELLO SUGAR, GOODBYE...

At the crux of it all, these food-goals are measurable. The challenge is to prove I can live without something. I don’t need it—I just want it. And while I think I’ve made a big enough adjustment to the way I shop and consume food for good, moving forward, I will reward myself with the occasional treat or a slice of birthday cake.

This year, I was toying with giving up a weakness that has little to no nutritional value. Hot chips. I caved on January 1. But what did McGrice suggest? “You’re not going to want to hear the answer,” she laughs. “I would say alcohol.” While she says the high-kilojoule vice is the one thing she knows improves many issues, I’m not quite ready for that sort of commitment.

For those looking to make a food resolution this year, my advice is to start small and take the time to acknowledge how your body is adjusting and reacting to the change.

Casey Vassallo is a freelance writer. Follow her on Instagram and visit her website for more.

Article Sources
MyDomaine uses only high-quality, trusted sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial guidelines to learn more about how we keep our content accurate, reliable and trustworthy.
  1. Sugar 101. American Heart Association. April 17, 2018

  2. The 5 Best (and Worst) Sweeteners You Can Eat. Cleveland Clinic. April 28, 2020

  3. Taleb H, Maddocks SE, Morris RK, Kanekanian AD. The Antibacterial Activity of Date Syrup Polyphenols Against S. Aureus and E. ColiFront Microbiol. 2016;7. doi:10.3389/fmicb.2016.00198

  4. Katta R, Desai SP. Diet and Dermatology: The Role of Dietary Intervention in Skin DiseaseJ Clin Aesthet Dermatol. 2014;7(7):46-51.

  5. 5 Ways to Fight Fatigue With Food. Cleveland Clinic. August 17, 2020

  6. Nutritional Psychiatry: Your Brain on Food. Harvard Medical School. March 26, 2020

  7. Tedeschi SK, Frits M, Cui J, et al. Diet and Rheumatoid Arthritis Symptoms: Survey Results from a Rheumatoid Arthritis RegistryArthritis Care Res. 2017;69(12):1920-1925. doi:10.1002/acr.23225

Related Stories